Thursday, March 2, 2017

Wine & Presidential Politics

When today's guest mentioned anxiety about potentially being selected as a featured wine at President Trump's inauguration earlier this year, it made me curious about the wine industry's support for the two main presidential candidates during last year's election. Using donation data reported to the Federal Election Commission, we can see which companies - more specifically, which companies' employees - donated to each presidential campaign. My hypothesis, given the concentration of the domestic wine industry in CA and the leftward leanings of the state, is that Hillary Clinton likely received more wine company donations than Donald Trump. But let's see what the data says! Below you can see the donations by employer for each presidential campaign from companies that have either "wine" or "vineyard" in their name:



Donations by Company/Employer to Donald J Trump for President Campaign
10/20/16 - 11/28/16
EMPLOYER SUM OF DONATIONS
CALIFORNIA WINE SERVICES $125
CARROLL GARDENS WINES & LIQUORS $250
IMPORT ANT WINES INC $250
MAUGLE SIERRA VINEYARDS LLC $250
PEJU WINERY $100
SANTA MARIA VINEYARD & WINERY $200
VILLA SAN JULIETTE WINERRY $100
WINE CONSULTANTS INC. $250
WOODS WHOLESALE WINE $2,000
Total $3,525

Source: http://docquery.fec.gov/pres/2016/30G/C00580100/A_EMPLOYER_C00580100.html


Donations by Company/Employer to Hillary for America Campaign
10/20/16 - 11/28/16


EMPLOYER SUM OF DONATIONS
ABC FINE WINE AND SPIRITS $25
ADELSHEIM VINEYARD $75
ALPHA OMEGA WINERY $25
ALTA RESTAURANT & WINE BAR $148
ALTRIA/STE MICHELLE WINE ESTATES $150
ARGONAUT WINE & LIQUOR $150
ASTOR WINES $98
BARNEY`S WINE $375
BELLUS WINES $800
BOUNTY HUNTER RARE WINE & SPIRITS $47
BOUNTY HUNTER WINES $239
CABIN VINEYARD, LLC $99
CHAPTER 24 VINEYARDS $800
CONSORT WINE TOURS $225
CONVINO WINE BAR $80
COUGAR CREST WINERY $55
CUTRUZZOLA VINEYARDS $225
DEWITT FAMILY WINES $50
DEWITT FAMILY WINES, LLC $25
DICKSON WINE BAR $300
DOS ROBLES VINEYARDS $760
E&J GALLO WINERY $125
ELMARO VINEYARD $174
FETZER VINEYARDS $200
FRANKLIN HILL VINEYARDS $50
FULL CIRCLE WINE SOLUTIONS $100
FULL PULL WINES $50
GARDEN CREEK VINEYARDS $100
GARY FARRELL WINERY $100
GLOBAL WINE COMPANY $45
GLOBAL WINE PARTNERS $75
GRAND CRU WINE CONSULTING $1,600
GUARACHI WINE PARTNERS $55
HAWLEY WINERY $124
HENRY WINE GROUP $100
JACKSON FAMILY WINES $100
K & M WINES $74
KING ESTATE WINERY $250
KNAPP WINERY $37
LEDE FAMILY WINES $125
MAC`S CREEK WINERY $110
MATCHBOOK WINE COMPANY $100
MDC WINES $100
MOUNT EDEN VINEYARDS $200
MT. BEAUTIFUL WINES $10
NEW YORK WINE & GRAPE FOUNDATION $825
OREGON WINE MARKETING $25
PACIFIC PRIME WINES $150
PAUMANOK VINEYARDS $100
PIKE AND WESTERN WINE $160
PRIDE MOUNTAIN VINEYARDS $150
PURPLE WINE AND SPIRITS $508
REGAL WINE IMPORTS $76
ROSENTHAL WINE MERCHANT $150
RUTHERFORD RANCH WINERY $100
SOUTHERN GLAZER`S WINE & SPIRITS $427
SOUTHERN WINE & SPIRITS $50
SOUTHERN WINE & SPIRITS OF NEW YORK $25
SOUTHERN WINE AND SPIRITS $250
SOUTHERN WINES AND SPIRITS $500
STAGS` LEAP WINERY $25
STANDING STONE VINEYARDS $75
STE MICHELLE WINE ESTATES $60
SUMMIT WINE TASTINGS $260
SUNBREAK VINEYARD MANAGEMENT SERVICES $60
T. EDWARD WINES $50
TERLATO WINES $25
TESTAROSSA WINERY $75
THE WINE CLUB $20
THE WINE GODDESS $120
THE WINE VAULT $335
THE WOODHOUSE WINE ESTATES $15
TOP SHELF SPIRIT & WINE $10
TOTAL WINE & MORE $348
TRAVELING VINEYARD $125
TREASURY WINE ESTATES $35
UNION SQUARE WINES $300
UVA WINES $2,700
VASHON WINERY $20
VINE TO WINE RESOURCES $80
VINEYARD BRANDS $100
WINE & DESIGN CHAPEL HILL $20
WINE & SPIRITS MAGAZINE $375
WINE BUSINESS MONTHLY $42
WINE INSTITUTE $450
WINE TIME $37
WINE WAREHOUSE $55
WINE.COM $25
WINERY EXCHANGE $100
WINERY OWNER CHARTER OAK WINERY $88
WINES FROM MEXICO $250
WINES LLC $50
WINESTORE $25
X WINERY $87
Total $18,693

Source: http://docquery.fec.gov/pres/2016/30G/C00575795/A_EMPLOYER_C00575795.html

As you can see, employees of wine-related companies overwhelmingly supported (at least financially) Hillary Clinton over Donald Trump. An interesting follow-on would be to measure the wine industry's contributions to PACs &  SuperPACs to see if company contributions followed the same trends as their employee contributions.


3 comments:

  1. This is awesome, thanks for pulling together! I wonder if other pieces of the wine value chain - distributors and retailers, specifically - share this trend. I think it might be less extreme in the difference, especially on the distributor front. But, that's just a hunch!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I was also intrigued by this comment and it prompted me to look up the wines that were selected.

    The wines that were served at Trump's Inauguration Luncheon were:
    - J. Lohr’s Arroyo Vista Chardonnay 2013 (~$25/bottle)
    - Black Stallion Estate Winery’s limited release Cabernet Sauvignon 2012 (~$60/bottle)
    - Korbel’s Special Inaugural Cuvée of ‘California Champagne’ (~$15/bottle for the version without inaugural seal)

    The wines were selected by the Joint Congressional Committee on Inaugural Ceremonies who asked the Wine Institute, California wine industry’s advocacy and public policy group, for recommendations. All of the selected wines are from California and are members of the Wine Institute.


    ReplyDelete
  3. Fascinating!

    I was surprised by how small the figures were. I went back and had a look through the two datasets you referenced. According to the data, Hillary received $33.7M in donations from companies and Trump received $7.7M.

    Based on this it looks like the wine industry only accounted for 0.06% and 0.05% of the company donations for Hillary and Trump respectively. I fully realize that a number of companies would have been missed based on the 'wine' and 'vineyard' search, but it still seems low. I wonder if these figures accurately reflect the degree of influence which the wine industry has in the political world...

    ReplyDelete