Thursday, January 26, 2017

Biodynamics in the Almond Industry -- Yea Right!


After our class last week on biodynamics in the wine industry I thought I'd take an introspective look at my own family heritage in the almond industry to see if anyone was implementing these techniques. Without stringing the reader along too much... they are absolutely NOT.

I'm not trying to debate the merits of using this horticulture practice vs. traditional methods. But I will say that different industries generally developed best practices over a period of time for a practical reason. For wine, those reasons seem to be vastly different than for agriculture products that are pure commodities. Wine growing seems to be as much an art as it is a science. Grape growers love, nurture and painstakingly monitor each plants progress. Almonds, on the other hand, are produced on a strictly commercial basis where P&L is a primary concern.

I've never seen and almond consumer admire the smell, taste, and texture of each individual nut--but this practice is the very essence of wine tasting. I think this consumption experience, or lack thereof,  is the fundamental reason that biodynamic farming isn't as popular in other ag industries as it is in the wine industry. Most ag products aren't appreciated for the way they make you "feel". Perhaps there is a segment of the market that savors every bite of an apple, and the sweet aroma of parsley--but I've never seen it. I'd venture to guess that the more an agriculture product is enjoyed for the experience it creates, the more likely it will be to use growing methods like biodynamic farming.

2 comments:

  1. Interesting to see the perspective from a different ag industry. Does the almond industry use any "category signaling" to attempt to educate the consumer on potential quality differences?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thank you for this. It is interesting to hear your reaction to biodynamic farming as a conventional almond grower. However, I don't think that sustainability and profitability have to be mutually exclusive ideas - even in almond farming. Biodynamism may be taking it too far, but the concept of treating a farm as a living system is one that may be of great value to crops beyond wine grapes. An agroecological farm system aims to replicate the self-regulating abilities of a natural ecosystem, and thereby reduce reliance on chemical and other inputs to the farm. For instance, creating natural habitat for bees in the form of hedgerows can dramatically reduce your reliance and expenditure on commercial pollination services. Meanwhile, the organic price premium would allow you to sell your product at a greater price. I understand the problem is more complex than this - that you can't just throw in a hedgerow to eliminate your reliance on commercial pollination. But I do think there is something to be said for applying the forward-thinking, innovative mentality promoted at GSB to older industries like farming.

    ReplyDelete